Quick navigation:   

Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

Posted By Message

The Original 2nd-time-around
Scottys Little Sister!

Member since 12/02

5659 total posts

Wedding Date:
5/4/2004 6:00 PM

Wed. Location:

Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

If so, how was it and do they have them ready made or do you need to order it in advance??

TIA

Posted 2/26/05 9:55 AM
 

Valentinegirl
*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*

Member since 7/03

7281 total posts

Wedding Date:
2/14/2004 3:00 PM

Wed. Location:
Westbury Manor-A+

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

I think they have ready made but my BIL ordered one in advance cause we wanted certain flavors. It was so good!

Posted 2/26/05 9:58 AM
 

Jax430
Beyond Obsession

Member since 3/03

7661 total posts

Wedding Date:
6/27/2004 6:00 PM

Wed. Location:
East Meadow Jewish Center

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

We had one for my SIL's b-day and it was SO good! They cost a fortune though! I think hers was already made b/c it was a special holiday cake with peppermint ice cream and candy canes...very yummy!


Posted 2/26/05 10:18 AM
 

Stefanie
Married 5 long years!!

Member since 7/03

1814 total posts

Wedding Date:
8/4/2002 4:00 PM

Wed. Location:
North Ritz Club

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

I heard that place was expensive...for ice cream. I tried one of their shakes once and I thinkI like Carvel better...

yum...shakes....

Posted 2/26/05 10:48 AM
 

palebride
Intercourse knows no season...

Member since 6/03

12375 total posts

Wedding Date:
4/3/2004 12:00 PM

Wed. Location:
Watermill

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

I LOVE LOVE LOVE their cakes!
yes, very expensive...but the one i had had a brownie bottom crust.....perfection!!!

Posted 2/26/05 11:15 AM
 

Valentinegirl
*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*

Member since 7/03

7281 total posts

Wedding Date:
2/14/2004 3:00 PM

Wed. Location:
Westbury Manor-A+

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?


Posted by palebride

I LOVE LOVE LOVE their cakes!
yes, very expensive...but the one i had had a brownie bottom crust.....perfection!!!



That sounds so good!

Posted 2/26/05 11:53 AM
 

OSCARtheGROOM
Kings of estrogen free posse!

Member since 3/04

3191 total posts

Wedding Date:
7/10/2005 3:00 PM

Wed. Location:
Villa Lombardi's

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

It's really hit or miss there. Sometimes they have them pre-made or you can order one.

Posted 2/26/05 11:54 AM
 

palebride
Intercourse knows no season...

Member since 6/03

12375 total posts

Wedding Date:
4/3/2004 12:00 PM

Wed. Location:
Watermill

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

now i want to go buy one.....

Posted 2/26/05 11:55 AM
 

The Original 2nd-time-around
Scottys Little Sister!

Member since 12/02

5659 total posts

Wedding Date:
5/4/2004 6:00 PM

Wed. Location:

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?


Posted by Stefanie

I heard that place was expensive...for ice cream. I tried one of their shakes once and I thinkI like Carvel better...

yum...shakes....



I am not really crazy about their ice cream either, but DH LOVES it and tomorrow is his B-day.
I just called there, and you can special order, but they need 2 days, or they have about 130 cakes pre-made.

Posted 2/26/05 12:26 PM
 

StepherG
Due 8/25/05!

Member since 7/03

1940 total posts

Wedding Date:
8/1/2004 4:30 PM

Wed. Location:
Watermill

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

I think they are $39.99 for a small cake!! EXPENSIVE!!!!

Posted 2/26/05 12:34 PM
 

lvdolphins
Robbie Says "HI"

Member since 4/04

3578 total posts

Wedding Date:
10/24/1999 3:30 PM

Wed. Location:
Watermill A+++++

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

Cakes are So good!!! Yes, they are pricey, but so worth it.
We had a cookie dough one, my brothers fave is the mint choc. chip.

Posted 2/26/05 12:45 PM
 

12-3Princess
WE'RE HOMEOWNERS!

Member since 12/04

3093 total posts

Wedding Date:
10/29/2005 3:30 PM

Wed. Location:
Tribeca Rooftop - NYC

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

yes and they're the beeeeeeest... mmm we had red velvent cake with i can't remember what flavor ice cream but prob vanilla... anyway, it was so good.

they have ready-made as well as made-to-order.

Posted 2/26/05 2:15 PM
 

Butterflybride
Loving my baby boy!!!

Member since 7/04

6745 total posts

Wedding Date:
1/15/2005 6:00 PM

Wed. Location:
The Swan Club (vow renewal-5/22/05)

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?


Posted by Stefanie

I heard that place was expensive...for ice cream. I tried one of their shakes once and I thinkI like Carvel better...

yum...shakes....



DH and I love their ice cream, but DH had a shake there and hated it. Now you've got me craving a shake though. I might just have to go get one now.

Posted 2/26/05 2:23 PM
 

Mel_and_Dave
Board Fanatic

Member since 3/04

334 total posts

Wedding Date:
9/6/2004 12:00 AM

Wed. Location:
Westbury Manor

Re: Has anyone gotten a cake from Cold Stone Creamery?

they are good but sooooooooooo bad for you. I had it once and my co-worker sent me to thier site to look at the nutrition charts! I was like OMG!! I hate her now! LOL

Posted 2/26/05 4:50 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Cake Batter is back at Cold Stone Creamery!!! nycshooz 10/29/05 5 NWR
Cold Stone Creamery Fans . . . (may have already been posted) BriBri529 7/5/05 6 NWR
I went to Cold Stone Creamery in woodbury last nite, here is my review! LOL Samanthas Mom 4/27/03 22 NWR
Cold Stone Cake Batter tracyg 7/27/05 14 NWR
Cold Stone Creamery BMD'sPeanut 8/17/04 27 NWR
cold stone creamery janwinterbridejoy 7/18/04 31 NWR
 
Quick navigation:   
 
Currently 11981 users on the NYCityWeddings.com Chat
Featured Vendors
 
Bridal Planner Group